Wholesale Returns, Damage Claims and Freight Policies

Wholesale brands handle returns and damage claims through written terms the retailer sees before ordering. Returns usually cover the brand's own errors: defective or damaged goods, wrong items and short shipments. Unsold stock comes back only by agreement. Retailers report problems within a set claim window, nothing ships back without a return authorization (RA) number, and the brand inspects the goods before issuing a credit or refund. Freight policy belongs in the same terms.
Which returns should a wholesale brand accept?
Accept returns that fix the brand's own mistakes, and decide everything else account by account. Retail accounts buy to resell, so a wholesale return policy corrects defects, picking errors and missing units. It isn't a promise to take back slow sellers.
An accommodation return is a return the brand accepts as a favor, not an obligation, such as taking back unsold stock or swapping sizes for a key account. Approve each one case by case and attach conditions, such as a restocking fee or credit only.
| Accept (brand error) | By agreement only | Normally final sale unless faulty |
|---|---|---|
| Defective or damaged goods | Unsold stock | Cut-to-order or custom items |
| Wrong item, size or color | Size or color swaps | Personalized goods |
| Short shipments (credit missing units) | Accommodation returns for key accounts | Sale or closeout items |
How long should retailers have to report damage or shortages?
Long enough to unpack and count, short enough that the cause is still clear. There is no single right number: examples from brand wholesale policies range from 72 hours to 14 days after delivery. As growyourboutique.com tells retailers, "Receiving is quality control with a deadline, because most damage claims have a short window."
Count the window from delivery, not the ship date, so slow transit doesn't shorten it. Ask for the order number, the items and quantities affected, and photos, so you can decide quickly. Then treat the two kinds of claim differently:
- Shortages and picking errors are the brand's mistake. Credit the missing units or ship them.
- Transit damage may also need a carrier claim, and who files depends on your shipping terms. How to ship wholesale orders covers FOB points, labels, fulfillment and carrier claims.
Either way, the brand can credit or replace damaged goods under its own terms while any carrier claim runs.
What does a wholesale return authorization process look like?
A return authorization (RA, or RMA for return merchandise authorization) is the brand's written approval for a specific return, identified by a number on the package. Nothing should ship back without one.
- The retailer requests a return within your window, with the order number, items and reason.
- The brand approves or declines. An approval includes the RA number, a ship-back address and a deadline to send the goods.
- The retailer ships the goods with the RA number on the package.
- The brand checks what arrived against the RA: items, quantities and condition.
- The brand issues a credit or refund, less any restocking fee the terms allow.
Say who pays return freight. One clear rule: the brand pays when the return fixes its own error, and the retailer pays on accommodation returns.
When should a brand charge a restocking fee?
A restocking fee is an amount the brand deducts from the credit on a return that isn't its fault. Charge it on accommodation returns and on goods that come back unfit to resell. Don't charge it on defects, wrong items or short shipments, which are the brand's own errors.
Examples from brand wholesale policies range from 5% to 25%. They vary widely, so base yours on your real handling cost, write it down and apply it to every account the same way.
Should a brand issue a credit or a refund?
Credit toward the next order suits active accounts and keeps the money in the relationship. A refund fits when the retailer has paid and won't reorder soon, or when a whole order was wrong. If an account on net terms hasn't paid yet, adjust the open invoice rather than refunding money that never arrived. Wholesale payment terms explains how credits work with net terms. Either way, record each adjustment against the order so both sides see the same balance.
Which freight policy should a brand offer retail accounts?
Pick one policy, apply it to every comparable account and print it on the order form. Freight policy decides who pays the carrier. Record freight charges separately from delivery and risk terms; the shipping guide explains those mechanics.
| Freight policy | Trade-off |
|---|---|
| Retailer pays actual freight | Protects margin; adds friction to first orders |
| Prepaid and add | Brand controls carrier and packing; retailer sees the cost on the invoice |
| Free above a threshold | Nudges larger orders; brand absorbs freight on those |
| Freight allowance | Shares the cost; takes more explaining |
| Flat fee per order | Predictable for the retailer; brand absorbs the variance |
Prepaid and add means the brand pays the carrier and adds freight to the retailer's invoice. A freight allowance is a fixed amount or percentage the brand puts toward shipping. Some retailers, especially those used to marketplace ordering, may expect free freight above a set order value, so decide your answer before an account asks.
Does free freight on a small opening order pay off?
Only if the order still earns money after freight. The boutique-buying guide calls freight "proportionally brutal" on small orders, and a low opening minimum multiplies the effect: more first orders, each carrying close to a full shipping cost. Run a simple check with your own figures:
Margin left = (order value − cost of goods) − (carrier cost + packaging + packing time)
If what's left is too thin, keep the low minimum and charge freight, or offer free freight only above a set order value. You can also treat free freight on a first order as the cost of opening an account, but budget the subsidy rather than assuming future reorders will cover it. Wholesale minimums covers setting the minimum itself.
Where should returns and freight terms be written down?
On every document the retailer sees, starting before the order: the line sheet and order form, then the order confirmation and invoice. Consistent wording reduces confusion when a claim arises. Use the same wording each time for:
- which returns you accept and which are final
- the claim window and what a claim must include
- the RA requirement and who pays return freight
- the restocking fee and when it applies
- the freight policy and any free-freight threshold
Wholesale order documents explains where each term prints.
How can a brand keep returns and claims out of email threads?
Brandboom lets buyers create returns or report issues in the platform, and lets sellers track and process each one. Brandboom lets sellers issue credits for returns with a record of each adjustment, or refund supported payments in-platform. Your claim window, RA rules, restocking fee and freight policy still live in your written terms, and sellers apply them as they review each request.
FAQ
Which retailer returns should a wholesale policy cover?
A sensible written policy covers the brand's own errors: defective or damaged goods, wrong items and short shipments. Unsold stock and swaps come back only by agreement, often with a restocking fee or a credit-only rule. Whatever you decide, put it on the order form and invoice so retailers see it before they order.
What is the difference between an RA and an RMA?
None in practice. RA stands for return authorization and RMA for return merchandise authorization; both mean the brand's written approval for a specific return, identified by a number on the package. Pick one term and use it consistently in your terms, emails and paperwork, so retailers know a return without that number won't be accepted or credited.
Should a brand charge a restocking fee on defective goods?
No. Defects, wrong items and short shipments are the brand's own errors, so the retailer should get full credit or replacement. Restocking fees belong on returns that aren't the brand's fault, such as unsold stock taken back as a favor or goods returned unfit to resell. Examples from brand policies range from 5% to 25%; set yours from real handling costs.
How do you set a free-freight threshold for wholesale?
Start from your own costs, not a figure borrowed from another brand. Add carrier cost, packaging and packing time for a typical order, then find the order value where your margin still covers them comfortably. Set the threshold at or above that point, show it on the order form, and apply it the same way to every comparable account.